What Are the Best Cuts of Beef for a Holiday Roast?

The best cut of beef for a holiday roast depends on how you want to serve it. For a fork tender pot roast, pick a chuck or arm roast. For sliced roast beef on a platter, pick a sirloin roast or a tri tip. For shredded beef and next day sandwiches, pick a rump roast.

Classen's chuck, arm, sirloin, and rump roasts are Nebraska Black Angus beef and typically about 3 pounds each, per the product pages, so you can plan one or two for a Thanksgiving table.

Turkey gets the headlines, but beef can be the main dish or sit right next to the bird. The trick is matching the cut to the way you cook it, so the roast you carve is the one you pictured.

You want a holiday roast that comes out tender and full of flavor, without guessing at the meat counter.

Which beef roast is best for Thanksgiving dinner?

The best roast is the one that fits your cooking method. Nebraska Extension educator Bethany Johnston, in Beef Roast For The Holidays, says to ask how you plan to cook the roast before you buy it. Dry roasting suits naturally tender cuts. Braising, which is slow cooking with a little liquid under a lid, suits chuck and round roasts.

Here is how the Classen roasts line up, using the farm's own notes from each product page.

Classen cutWhat the farm saysBest way to cook itServe it as
Chuck RoastThe most marbled roast Classen offersBraise low and slowClassic pot roast
Arm RoastWell marbled, with a lean, tender, juicy textureBraise or slow cookPot roast or shredded beef
Sirloin RoastMid marbled, lean, tender, and juicyRoast with a thermometer, or cook slowlySliced roast beef
Tri Tip RoastFrom the bottom sirloin, for grilling, roasting, or smokingHot oven or grill, then slice across the grainSliced, for a smaller table
Rump RoastThe second leanest roast, great for shredded beef sandwichesSlow cookShredded beef and leftovers
Round RoastExtremely lean, great marinated, braised, or slow cookedMarinate, then braiseThin sliced or shredded
Brisket21 day dry aged, flat or pointSmoke low and slow, or roastSliced or chopped

The farm's note on the chuck, arm, sirloin, and rump roasts says each one becomes more flavorful, moist, and tender when cooked slowly. Want to know why marbling matters so much? Read the science behind beef marbling and flavor.

What is the best roast for a fork tender pot roast?

Chuck roast is the best pick for pot roast, and arm roast is a close second. Both are well marbled, and slow, moist heat turns them fork tender.

The Nebraska Extension method is simple. Brown the roast on all sides in a skillet with oil. Move it to a slow cooker or a large pan with a lid, add a half cup to 2 cups of broth or water, plus onions, carrots, celery, and seasoning if you like. Cover it and cook on low for 4 to 10 hours, depending on the temperature, until the meat is fork tender.

What is the best roast for sliced roast beef?

A sirloin roast or a tri tip is the best pick when you want neat slices on a platter. Both come from the sirloin and slice well across the grain.

The Kansas Beef Council holiday roast guide says tri tip roasts hot and fast at 425 degrees and, at 1 1/2 to 3 pounds, is a great fit for a smaller gathering. The same guide says to roast fat side up on a rack in a shallow pan with no water and no lid, rest the roast loosely tented with foil for 10 to 20 minutes, and carve across the grain.

For the sirloin roast, Classen's note says it gets more tender when cooked slowly, so use a lower oven temperature, check it with a thermometer, and slice it thin.

What temperature should a beef roast reach?

USDA says beef roasts are safe at 145 degrees F with at least a 3 minute rest. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service temperature chart lists 145 degrees F, measured with a food thermometer, for beef steaks, chops, and roasts.

Plan for carryover heat. Nebraska Extension says that for medium rare you can pull the roast at 130 degrees F, tent it with foil, and let it rest for 15 minutes, and the temperature keeps rising to 145 degrees F on the counter. A braised pot roast cooks well past that point on its way to fork tender.

How far ahead should you thaw a frozen roast?

Move a frozen roast to the refrigerator one to two days before you cook it. The USDA guide to safe defrosting says to allow at least a full day for every 5 pounds in a refrigerator at 40 degrees F or below, and that even small packages need a full day.

The same guide says a thawed beef roast stays good in the refrigerator for 3 to 5 days before cooking, so there is no harm in starting early. In a pinch, a 3 to 4 pound package in a leak proof bag thaws in cold water in about 2 to 3 hours if you change the water every 30 minutes, and then it should be cooked right away. Never thaw beef on the counter.

For a Thursday dinner, a Classen roast of about 3 pounds can go into the refrigerator on Tuesday. More tips are in our post on how long beef lasts in the freezer.

How do you get a Classen roast for Thanksgiving?

Order your roast early so there is time to thaw it. Shop the roast collection, then call 531-810-1107 to set pickup or delivery before your holiday. Smaller orders ship by UPS on Tuesdays, and checkout shows the shipping cost for your address.

Cooking for an Omaha table? See how pickup and delivery work on the Omaha beef page.

If you want roasts all winter, a beef share brings home roasts along with steaks, ground beef, and specialty cuts. See how a beef share works, or reserve a share from an upcoming harvest.

Shop beef roasts

Questions about which roast fits your table? Call 531-810-1107 or email info@classenmercantile.com.

FAQ

What is the best cut of beef for a holiday roast?

It depends on how you serve it. Chuck or arm roast makes the best pot roast. Sirloin roast or tri tip is best for sliced roast beef. Rump roast is best for shredded beef and sandwiches.

Which roast is best for pot roast?

Chuck roast. It is the most marbled roast Classen offers, and slow, moist heat makes it fork tender. Arm roast is a good second choice.

What temperature should a beef roast be cooked to?

USDA lists 145 degrees F with at least a 3 minute rest for beef roasts. Nebraska Extension notes you can pull a roast at 130 degrees F for medium rare, rest it under foil for 15 minutes, and it rises to 145 degrees F.

How long does a frozen beef roast take to thaw?

In the refrigerator, allow at least a full day for every 5 pounds, per USDA. A Classen roast of about 3 pounds can move to the refrigerator one to two days ahead. A thawed roast keeps 3 to 5 days in the refrigerator before cooking.

How big is a Classen roast?

Classen's chuck, arm, sirloin, and rump roasts are typically about 3 pounds each, per the product pages.

Do beef shares include roasts?

Yes. A Classen beef share is a mix of ground beef, roasts, steaks, and specialty cuts, so you can keep roasts on hand all winter.

Next
Next

How Does a Beef Share Work, From Reserve to Freezer?